Langsung ke konten utama

Response paper to Clifford Geertz: The Religion of Java (Theories of Religion and Society)


Geertz’ concept about Abangan, Santri and Priyayi is no longer enough to analyze the religious differentiation in Javanese today because he has lack of understanding of each group, especially Santri’s development today. Geertz has a great idea how to analyze and see the religio-social reality in Java with his concept of that 3 groups. But it still does not work to analyze the rapid development now, especially in Santri’s group.
Geertz has identified Javanese people into 3 groups, Abangan, Santri and Priyayi. The Abangan is a representation of farmer, Priyayi for bureaucracy and Santri for seller in the market. This identification was so helpful at the time and became the majority perspective for long time. As the time goes by, this categorization has many critics and disagreement from other scholars. The main critique is the application of those categories into the reality of Javanese today. Many critiques said that for example, if someone was identified as an Abangan now, how do We know that he is an Abangan people. If he is a farmer, it does not work well when we see that many farmers in village are Santri too, they go to mosque and pray there.
Most of the Geertz’ categorization of Javanese people is not applicable in the reality. Some scholars, for example, Abdul Munir Mulkhan had given another categorization for Javanese people, especially in Santri’s group. He categorized that know we have an hybrid group between Abangan, Santri and Priyayi. His thesis called “Santrinisasi birokrasi and Birokratisasi Santri” tells us about the diffusion of each group’s role from the sharing power in the government. This categorization is based on the research on Suharto’s era, when Suharto has recruited many people to be bureaucrats. This policy has converted many people to be hybrid group because Suharto used many terms and rules from religious values, especially Islam.
Today, the Greetz’ categorization is not imposed as majority analysis in Javanese or generally Indonesian people because it has many contradiction in the reality. Although it does not work well now, Geertz has given us the new perspective for knowing the people’s constellation since his theory was released and influenced many studies of Indonesian people. 
Label:

Komentar

Posting Komentar

Thanks for your comment. God bless you always. :)

Postingan populer dari blog ini

The Toughest Week

I would genuinely say that this week is one of the hardest. Problems visit like a flood, not giving me some time to breathe. However, I fortunately feel okay, considering it as a process that can make me stronger. First, my boss decided to cut off my salary this morning because of giving the batiks that I should make into office's uniform into my friend from Philippine. I did it because I felt bad to invite him to my pesantren without handing over such souvenir. I thought that I can buy it another batiks which has similar pattern (kawung) at Beringharjo market. However, my boss had different view and the result is that he punished me by cutting my salary as a substitute to price of batiks he provided to me. It is rather funny I guess, but I will not make a mess with that small problem. I should fully accept it as a risk when I hand my office's gift into other. Second, I failed to secure some money to pay rent for the house. Therefore, I turn up into the last choice to ...
Posting Komentar
Baca selengkapnya

Berotak Tekad, Berhati Malaikat; a Tribute to Undar Jombang

18 September 1965, tanggal kelahiran Undar Jombang. Sudah begitu tua, setua Gus Mujib, Neng Eyik dan Gus Lukman yang sampai sekarang masih menjadi penguasa-penguasa Undar, asyik mengangkangi “tahta kecil” mereka. Tapi Undar memang istimewa, biarpun dihantam krisis kepemimpinan sejak lama, sampai sekarang masih saja berdiri kukuh. Menantang langit, mengukir jaman. Undar selalu ada, tapi sedihnya, mungkin ia juga pelan-pelan menjadi tiada. Timbul tenggelam, mencari pegangan kesana kemari tanpa pertolongan siapapun. Bukan karena tidak ada yang menolong, tapi karena Undar sendiri yang menolaknya. Di stasiun Purwokerto, jam 6 pagi pada akhir Juli 2004, aku bersama seorang sahabat karib menaiki kereta Logawa jurusan Purwokerto – Surabaya. Tiket seharga 21 ribu selalu kupegang erat-erat. Ini perjalananku pertama kali yang jauh dari Cilacap, kota kelahiranku. Hari itu, aku dan temanku berangkat ke Jombang, untuk nyantri dan kuliah di Universitas Darul Ulum Jombang. Sejak melihat brosur ka...
Posting Komentar
Baca selengkapnya

Nyonya Indon

Apa reaksi anda ketika mendengar orang Malaysia atau Singapura menyebut Indonesia dengan kata "Indon"? Marah, jengkel dan tidak suka? atau biasa-biasa saja? Aku lebih memilih reaksi kedua. Bukan karena nasionalisme yang kurang, tapi karena pertemuanku dengan ibu masinis MRT ini, jum'at kemarin. Secara kebetulan, kami bertiga ketemu ini di MRT. Ibu ini bekerja sebagai masinis di MRT jurusan Harbour Front. Berpakain seragam SMRT (Singapore Mass Rapid Transportation) yang merah hitam, ibu ini nampak melayu karena kerudung yang dikenakannya, dan terutama sekali, logatnya yang khas. Ibu ini sudah mafhum bahwa kami bertiga berasal dari Indonesia. Aku yang penasaran, bertanya darimana asal beliau. Jawabnya bisa ditebak, beliau melayu keturunan Indonesia yang tinggal lama di Singapura. Asalnya dari Kepulaun Riau. Bahkan dia bilang, akhir minggu ini seharusnya dia pulang ke Riau, tapi gagal disebabkan anaknya yang juga jadi masinis MRT tidak bisa mengantar kesana. Sang anak me...
Posting Komentar
Baca selengkapnya